On Behalf of Human Dignity
I’ve never seen the TV show “The Wire” because I don’t have HBO. But I can tell you that later today I’m going to rent copies of the dvd and start watching it all the way through its 4 seasons. That’s because I just finished reading an article by William Hughes over at The Black Commentator (thanks for the link Blueneck) that describes a speech by its creator David Simon.
Simon predicts the end of the American Empire as the result of the triumph of capitalism over humanity.
Simon started: “I am wholly pessimistic about American society. I believe The Wire is a show about the end of the American Empire. We…are going to live that event. How we end up…and survive [and] on what terms, is going to be the open question… There will be cities. We are an urban people…What kind of places they will be are…dependent on how we behave toward each other and how our political infrastructure behave…
But what I found most interesting in all this, is Simon’s thoughts about why this is happening:
Continuing, Simon emphasized: “We are in the postindustrial age. We do not need as many of us as we once did. We don’t need us to generate capital…to secure wealth. We are in a transitive period where human beings have lost some of their value. Now, whether or not we…can figure out a way to validate the humanity of the individual…I have great doubts…We (America) haven’t figured out the answers to these questions. I have doubts whether anyone is going to be able to do it…
As for the characters on the program, Simon explained, “Their lives are less and less necessary. They are more and more expendable. The institutions in which they serve…are indifferent…to their existence.”
This spoke to me on so many levels. First of all, like Simon, I see the effects of this indifference daily in the lives of urban youth and families. I keep trying to tell myself that if people knew how these families lived…they’d care. And sometimes I get that confirmation from individuals. But for the most part, the system as a whole gives it all a big yawn. We might care about an individual we hear about, but their is absolutely NO interest in changing the system that continues to put urban families in these circumstances.
Here’s Simon about why…
“I didn’t start [out] as a cynic…,” Simon underscored, “but at every given moment, where this country has had a choice…its governments…institutions…corporations, its social framework…to exalt the value of individuals over the value of the shared price, we have chosen raw unencumbered Capitalism. Capitalism has become our God… You are not looking at a Marxist up here…But you are looking at somebody who doesn’t believe that Capitalism [can work] absent a social framework that accepts that it is relatively easy to marginalize more and more people in this economy…[Capitalism] has to be attended to. And that [this attending] has to be a conscious calculation on the part of society, if that is going to succeed…” If it doesn’t succeed, Simon predicted, “You are eventually going to have the gated communities and the people inside saying: ‘Isn’t it a shame you can’t drive downtown anymore’. That is where we are headed…[towards] separate Americas…Everywhere we have created an Alternate America of haves and have-nots…At some point, either more of us are going to find our conscience or we’re not.” Simon believes that the city is basically “the victim” of this ongoing brutal process of “unencumbered Capitalism.”
None of this comes as any surprise to me or to any of you. The only question remaining is, can we do anything to change it? Can we find the value of humanity and hold it up as worthy? And what will have to change to make that happen? Its not just in our war zones that we are fighting for “hearts and minds.” I think that it is right here in our midst. I think its about each of us, engaging those around us one person at a time, and holding up their humanity as something that we value, inviting them to do the same. And challenging the many ways that daily, the value of our humanity is sacrificed on the alter of greed.
Here is the challenge that Simon leaves us with:
Simon described himself as a storyteller. He concluded his insightful and relevant remarks by stating: “The Wire is certainly an angry show. It’s about the idea that we are worth less. And that is an unreasonable thing to contemplate for all of us. It is unacceptable. And none of us wants to be part of a world that is going to do that to human beings. If we don’t exert on behalf of human dignity, at the expense of profit, and Capitalism and greed [which] are inevitabilities, [and] if we can’t modulate them in some way that is a framework for an intelligent society, we are doomed! It is going to happen sooner than we think. I don’t know what form it will take…But, I know that every year it [America] is going to be a more brutish, and cynical and divided place.”
They are more and more expendable. The institutions in which they serve…are indifferent…to their existence.
I forgot to add that this statement also grabbed me as a way I feel these days about affecting this administration. As I watch Bush/Cheney respond to us about issues like the war, it feels clear that we are expendable and they are totally indifferent to our existence.
Here’s one more quote from Simon:
It’s out of our control. And, it is even out of our control in a democratic sense…If you are going to go out and vote at the next election… your vote doesn’t matter…If you thought you were living in a democracy, if you bought into that, you gotta go to the dictionary and look up the word, Oligarchy. And, you have to really think about what it means.
I don’t mean to sound hopeless. Its just that I agree that if there is going to be change, we have to recognize what we are dealing with, and then adjust our strategies accordingly.
Comment by nlinstpaul — February 19, 2007 @ 11:18 am
OMG, I HAVE to see this too. This guy’s words hardly touched my brain, they zinged straight to my guts.
Nancy you are just a treasure for finding all this wonderful stuff, poetry, music, books..to share with us. Thank you so much.
Comment by scribe40 — February 19, 2007 @ 11:30 am
George Carlin gets it too.
For all of you on dial-up - this is a youtube video. And for those of you who watch, its just the first 4 1/2 minutes of this 9 minute clip that addresses the topic. After that, he goes off on a tangent.
And here’s the definition of “oligarchy” from wiki:
a form of government where political power effectively rests with a small, elite segment of society (whether distinguished by wealth, family or military prowess).
Comment by nlinstpaul — February 19, 2007 @ 11:41 am
Nancy, thank you once again, for sharing such deeply felt and discouraging thoughts. Since I am way too optimistic a person to let this really pull me down. . .although I have my moments of that as well. . .I think what he points out is clearly the battle in our midst. I also think that our feeling of not knowing really how to combat it makes it very difficult for us. We don’t yet seem to have enough tools on our side to overcome the media/greed/policy/authoritarian control that is smothering us. Like everything else, it is a process. I doubt that there will be any “magic wand” to wave and make it all better. But there is a process and we will each need to find our way through the process that will spark others into action and awareness. I think the most discouraging thing about so much of what is going on right now is the people’s deep feeling of helplessness.
There is a lot that needs to be done.
Hugs
Shirl
Comment by shirlstars — February 19, 2007 @ 12:23 pm
we’ve watched all seasons of it - I ennoy it for tv fare, & it does try to dramatize issues w/ no easy solution -I do recall Ishamel Reed somewhere unleashing some invective on Simon for what he saw as pre-dominately re-inforcing negative images of african-americans
(just looked at his mag’s (Konch) TOC & didn’t see anything, but you might find it innerestin’ anyway:
http://www.ishmaelreedpub.com/
Comment by arcturus1 — February 19, 2007 @ 6:08 pm
I thought I’d come back and make a comment now that I’ve watched 8 episodes of The Wire. My overall feeling is that its rough. But there are clearly moments when this message of Simon’s comes through.
Two that stand out in my mind happen when one of the leaders of the drug trade in the projects has conversations with a couple of his young “runners.”
One is a scene where he teaches them how to play chess - more metaphors there than you can count. And another is when they have a discussion about the person at McDonalds who invented chicken tenders. Its interesting how the leader “schools” the runners in how the system works in taking advantage of folks who do the leg work.
I think I quit watching last night as the whole inner city drama was about to break into the power structures. The cops had just made the first connection between the drug trade and money being funneled to those who are at the top of the power pyramid. We’ll see when I can watch more.
Comment by nlinstpaul — February 20, 2007 @ 8:13 am
Oh, and Arcturus, I think I’ll do a little research on your comment about criticism of the negative images of African Americans. My thought is that he has a mix of Caucasian and African Americans on all sides. And he seems to be adept at showing the shadow side of most everyone involved.
If you find anymore of those links, I’d appreciate knowing.
Comment by nlinstpaul — February 20, 2007 @ 8:19 am